Feedback for Obsidian Soul:
Phoebus bag is the "mars symbol" used for male.
Phoebus amulet is the "venus symbol" used for female.
You changed tiles for them dont show this anymore... (not a problem with TTF on)
'{' and '}' can be used for graphics if you have TTF on. Only one of them appears in one tile of the jewelers workshop.
';' is only used in mason, could be some sort of tool.
Filling/Inside color of nestbox, minecart and bucket.
Background color used for trunks of trees.
Background engraving color missing from floor under items.
- Example: Green background anvil has no green runes engraved in the floor around it.
Cyan/Brown color-tops of mushrooms could be white.
Armorstand and Statue use same top, might be confusing at the start for new users.
What are the left/right arrows in the second line used for?
Why is the barrel using the background color for the barrel, and why does it have a black background?
Sand looks... odd. I love most of the wavy-rock/soil types, but that one is maybe too much. Only personal opinion of course.
Thread uses Phoebus rope tile. Wile still fitting, I think that this might cause confusion.
Up and Down stairs are somewhat hard to distinquish. Might just be me though.
I love some of the wave patterns, the ash with broken ammo sticking out, the sword-arrows, the dead-creature icons and the meat. I would also like to try out the floor/walls once, but that is of course a bit more work. ^^
All in all I think this is a very nice set, and on par with Ironhand and Phoebus. If you completely finish it and make a nice thread about it, I see no reason why it shouldnt be as popular.
Would you be interested to work with me on this?
Meph x64 Tileset. I have the modding down to an art, but my actual art skills are lacking. Ignoring all creature sprites, just the tileset, that would be huge. Either x64 or x48. I think more people have use of x48.