Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Shakerag]

[Hey.  Hey you.  Post more.  Especially you, lynx_]

[zombie urist]

Day ends in ~11 hours.

0 to extend.
0 to shorten.

[MrCelt]

Extend

[Shakerag]

Extend

Also, zu, prod everyone.  In the eye. 

lynx_:  Post.  Give me your reads on all remaining players.

MrCelt:  Post.  Do something with the extend you're requesting.

Flandre:  Post.  Why don't you think Jim is the last scum?

Jim: Hang.

[Reverie]

Shakerag:

Everyone: Let's get back to the game now that the holidays are over.  Restate your case on who you're voting and why. 

Kingfisher/Borno/Kingfisher/MrCelt was a murky read during the first two days of the game due to general lack of material and all of the player-switching, and my read of MrCelt was a nervous one to begin with. Up until lately and especially after Scottzar left, he has been sitting passively on his vote and trying to remain neutral on matters, focusing solely on Scottzar's slot and using his absence as as excuse for waiting and not actively scumhunting. Through all of this he even made it clear that mislynching is not entirely unfavorable, and that nolynching was bad (despite doing nothing about the concurrent nolynch situation).  After apologizing and/or conceding to my points and with a pressure on him to actually do something, he cast a groundless vote on Jim and disappeared through the would-be end of the day, only following up afterwards with:

To those of you who asked: Why I'm voting Jim: I originally wanted that question answered, and I'm oblivious to american holidays, so didn't realise it was thanksgiving. - now his response was offputting, and as we have a ML to burn, there's no reason not to lynch someone who is quite scummy. - He's also voting me for no reason, either; He said it himself, he can see nothing scummy about myself other than me voting him..

   
...which only brings up his views on expendable lynches and his want for Jim to die with that as a justification. All still unsupported.

With that said...

Flandre:  Post.  Why don't you think Jim is the last scum?

I think that MrCelt is the remaining scum. I'm not really sold on your argument against Jim, and your strongest points in support of Scottzar being a noob and Jim trying to pass it off as a scumread have yet to be responded to. Of course I am still interested in seeing the answer, but as things stand now, I'm under the impression that he legitimately found Scottzar to be scummy.

Lynx_:

Any questions to keep in mind while I read through? I've been a bit busy but the weekend is creeping ever closer!

Giving us your views on the game is as good a place to start as any. Do you have any Mafia experience?     

[zombie urist]

Day extended to Monday, December 3rd.

0 to extend.
0 to shorten.

This BM has been running about twice as long as other BMs. Please think before extending. And please make use of extensions. If you are unable to post consistently consider asking for a replacement. I've been kinda lazy about prods but I'm going to start paying more attention to activity.

Please be active.

[Shakerag]

Day extended to Monday, December 3rd.

0 to extend.
0 to shorten.

This BM has been running about twice as long as other BMs. Please think before extending. And please make use of extensions. If you are unable to post consistently consider asking for a replacement. I've been kinda lazy about prods but I'm going to start paying more attention to activity.

Please be active.

To be fair, we did have a holiday during the game.

[zombie urist]

The holiday only lasted one day. 

[Reverie]

The holiday only lasted one day. 

♫ It's beginning to look a lot like Christmas ♫

[zombie urist]

Please don't let the game last that long.

And please start making substantial posts.

[Dariush]

And please start making substantial posts.

PROD EVERYONE AND MODKILL THE REST

[Urist Imiknorris]

Modkill all townies.

[lynx_]

Lynx_:Giving us your views on the game is as good a place to start as any. Do you have any Mafia experience?     

Not too much. I've played a few games off-site and many RL games at parties!

As for the game, I was quite surprised while reading through that CF was scum.
There wasn't a huge amount of content from them (sorry don't know anyone's preferred pronoun) but nothing there was too scummy.
It's a huge thread though, you guys post much more than on the other forum I played on, over there games are usually 10 pages long at the end, rather than 30. Hence it taking a good while for me to read through.

lynx_:  Post.  Give me your reads on all remaining players.

Please correct me if I get any facts wrong, as I don't have the hours I'd need to spare to read the entire thread comprehensively.
MrCelt: Lurky, and when he does post it looks like he's doing so whenever he comes under pressure. Appears to weakly attack Jim for OMGUS, then backs down when it doesn't take off.
Flandre: His predecessor was incredibly scummy on D1 IMO, and floundered about under pressure. I'm surprised he wasn't lynched much earlier in the game, to be honest. Flandre has been much more reasonable and asking good questions so an IGMEOY will suffice for now.
Shakerag: Has acted painfully townie right from the start. I'm not quite sure how he hasn't been killed, particularly with the doctor dead. Perhaps it means he's been off in his reads, or alternatively scum may be simply trying to spread wine.
Jim: Very aggressive, which on its own would be a townie thing but it appears that's his meta so that's a null-tell. Otherwise has been vote-hopping and seems to have honed in on a lurker after he failed to garner support for a Scottzar lynch.

I can't find it in the rules and I'm not used to votes in text, do you cut the day short with a majority vote? If so I currently have the opportunity to hammer either MrCelt or Jim. I'm leaning towards Jim at the moment, Shakerag why are you so sure he's scum?

[zombie urist]

there are no hammers in BMs.
pfp

[Shakerag]

It's a huge thread though, you guys post much more than on the other forum I played on, over there games are usually 10 pages long at the end, rather than 30. Hence it taking a good while for me to read through.

[This one is not the longest by far, but they typically run out to about this length or a bit more.]

Shakerag why are you so sure he's scum?

Here's a good start. 

lynx_:  And so ... do you find someone more scummy than the rest?  Either vote or start questioning/pressuring. 

The rest of you:  Start posting, assholes.  So help me god, if we keep dragging this out I'll throw the game to the scum willingly just to get it over with. 

MrCelt:  You got your extension (why the fuck did you extend?), now do something with it.  Drag your lurking ass back in here and post. 

Flandre:  That's a nice case you have there and all, but since we have a tie, what are you going to do now to convince everyone else to vote with you?

Jim:  Your "today" (28th) and "tomorrow" (29th) are past.  Call the fucking Ghostbusters and get your ass in here.

Modkill all townies.

Shut it, you.  Go prod your scumbuddy to post more.