Meph:The Vote Tally
Dariush: Bookthras
I voted
Orb#3, which in
this votecount seemed to be an unvote. I've not voted Dariush. Is this an error, or is there some vote weirdness going on?
Hmmm... Meph: Book looks around at the Orbs, and numbers them #1, #2, #3, #4, starting with the closest to the Statue's left arm and moving clockwise. Which Orb is the Skeleton closest to? Vote Orb #3. Votecount, please.
The Skeleton is next to Orb #2.
Book notices the skeleton position close to Orb #2, and addresses the Statue: "if this skeleton is selected for judgement, will it activate Orb #2, or a different Orb?"Meph: at the end of day one, will Orb #1 will be activated? Or will Orb #2 be it? Can we change this selection in any way? Is there a way for us to choose Orb #4 to be activated at the end of D1?
Deathsword:I think the skeleton might be the key to solving the puzzle since it can be voted, and thus lynched. I do not think there is anything to lose by making the skeleton touch the orb.
Tiruin:See answer above.
Hapah: Same thing. I think the skeleton is part of the puzzle.[...]
The other hypotesis, whomever makes the skeleton touch the orb dies, doens't leave much to speculate on.
Do you or do you not expect whoever makes the skeleton touch the orb to die?
Still haven't answered the very basic question:
who should be lynched today and why?Still not a single original thought. I continue to vote
Deathsword until he can rub two neurons together to conjure a synapse. Also: are you avoiding
Org? If not, please say your opinion on him and ask him a question.
Shakerag:We can vote. For something in the flavor.[...]
Bastard Paranormal 1 - No one figured out the mechanics, scum won.
Bastard Paranormal 2 - I was scum, and used the mechanics to scum victory.
Yeah, sure, but there was more than voting involved in both. BP1, you were supposed to find the
hidden scum; BP2, you were supposed to find the other
hidden scum. Where do you think the hidden scum is hiding now, or do you think the skeleton is scum, or how do you think voting it will out the hidden scum? Do you think it possible that
the hidden scum is voting skeleton as an easy scapegoat?
Jim:I don't know what the next step is because I don't know what voting the fucking skeleton is going to do. If it does nothing, whatever. If it does something, cool, ask me the question again. If the skeleton stands up and does a jig and pulls a 6-pack out of his rib cage, even better.
But I don't know what's going to happen until the skeleton gets fucking lynched.
But it can only be lynched if people vote skeleton instead of scum. Do you think people should not vote for whoever they think is scummiest? Should they vote skeleton instead?
Mephansteras never said for certain that the person second highest in votes would be the one to help the skeleton activate the Orb, he merely presented it as one option, so I think it's ultimately up to us how we decide who helps the skeleton along. I say Tiruin do it, because he already volunteered. And I think he's scum, so if the Orb fries him, I get everything I want out of Day 1.
This is extremely disingenuous. Yes, Meph left open the option of a volunteer, who is very likely to die doing it. Do you really think a scum is going to do that? (say if you do). If no volunteers, then Meph clearly has stated that the second-most voted will be it (lynched/activate it/puppet the skeleton to activate it). Whoever has move votes (non-skeleton) can do that too. So, the second-most voted after skeleton will be (effectively) lynched... therefore voting skeleton is failing to vote for whoever is scummiest.
Who do you think should be lynched today and why? If your choice was between
Skeleton or that person actually being lynched, who would you choose and why?
Since it bears repeating, the skeleton is the only flavor exploration that actually did anything. I don't know why so many of you are shitting on the only thing that showed any results.
I think you got sort of a hard-on about your half-assed exploration actually hitting gold, and that's why you won't regard it objectively. Yeah, it's good, but it's not
so good that people should vote it instead of scum!
Toaster:I still disagree that it was wasted time in the first place- it's not like he did it exclusively.
Give it up. At the time, I thought he was not sincere, so I questioned it. Shouldn't I have? At this point I have to wonder what you have to gain from bringing it up again. Are you trying to make a big deal of it so people battle about it rather than focus on your very limited, lurky, noncommittal contributions so far?
Would you vote skeleton? Who should be lynched and why? What do you think of Hapah, Deathsword and Tiruin? less than 24hrs from day end, why aren't you voting?
Summary: Deathsword is scummiest for lack of hunting and jumping on others' arguments without an original thought, as scum would try to do D1;
Tiruin is being suspiciously addle-minded;
Jim is scummy for his love affair with the skeleton;
Org, Toaster & Shakerag are suspect for being (active)lurky noncommittal non-opinion scum.
All those bolded above:
who do you think should be lynched and why? What would your second choice be?