So our stories of shield using superdwarves and their crazy rock obsessed lovers have won you over huh?
Ok putting Tulx into the lineup.
EDIT: Tulx in lineup.
Also speaking of Captain Mountainhomes, I was running some tests in Arena mode with dwarves of his general proficiency level with a shield and I got some pretty horrifying results. I put him up against a dwarf with the exact same stats who was equipped with a shield AND a weapon and it was pretty consistent that he loses against those with slashing weapons, I.E short swords, battle axes. However he began winning against those with hammers and spears pretty consistently (and on those occasions rather rapidly I might add) which started to get my hopes up. But then I put him in with gobbos who used a shortsword with no skills. One-on-One he killed four before dying, however when even 1 extra gobbo was added it turned really depressing. He kept dying, so I upgraded his equipment from the wood shield to an iron one (the gobbos were using copper swords) no change. On a whim gave him TWO shields (yes they WILL dual wield shields) which seemed to increase his survival slightly, but did not give him any real edge on the gobbos, just drew out how much torment he received before dying. So, fed up with these gobbos I gave the next one ADAMANTINE EVERYTHING, dual adamantine shields and as a joke, an elf leather cloak. HE FRAKKING LOST. HOW DO YOU LOSE WHEN YOUR DECKED OUT IN ADAMANTINE AND THEY USE COPPER? THE FUCK? Repeated. LOST AGAIN. Repeated with him having a adamantine short sword and a shield. That'll teach those greenskin bastards.....EXCEPT HE LOST....THE FUCK? I finally just said screw it and gave him grandmaster skill in everything and that did it. Then I kinda just turned the arena into a clusterfuck of Giant Recluse Spider Mummies, Vampire Hydras, Vampire SPERM WHALE MEN, and a Zombie Dragon.....yeah that happens when I use the arena
But anyway, anyone have any ideas to make him more effective? Is it just an issue of him being outnumbered? Would just increasing the militia help? Arena mode doesn't take attributes into account, would increasing his strength and such work? What do you think Talvi, you have experience with superdwarves (Fischer, Draignean)