Fifteen minutes after we last heard from the 4th Armored, not much has changed. The 66th Armored Field Artillery Battalion has orders to lay down fire on the concentration of units around the city center, but has run out of ammunition.
The TO&E for the 66th is kind of interesting. The obvious bulk of the unit comes from the 105mm Howitzer Motor Carriages M7 (which you probably know as the Priest via World of Tanks), but it's got an impressive amount of organic transport capacity, and although 200 carbines, M1 isn't a great deal of infantry firepower, it's probably more than sufficient to hold off small-scale attacks.
Anyway, according to Wikipedia, all the US armored divisions involved in the Battle of the Bulge had three motorize artillery battalions, which gave them "unparalleled" mobile fire support. I buy that.
Obviously, another fifteen minutes isn't enough to make much progress, but it does give me a useful window in which to comment on the boundaries of the St. Vith objective: the villages to the southwest and south serve as convenient visual references, as do the vees in the road to the west, the highway to the north, and the rail line to the north-northeast. I'll call the edge of the industrial district west of city center the eastern border. Or rather, I'll suggest you do that; I can just pop on the indicator whenever I feel the need to check, but I don't usually take many screenshots of them.
D Company of the 37th Tank Battalion, the one that was nearly obliterated on the highway south of St. Vith yesterday, has recovered from its rout and attempts to surrender, and, by spearheading the attack on the western flank with a mere two M5 Stuarts, is demonstrating a great deal of pluck.
At 4:00pm on D4, A Company of the 704th Tank Destroyer Battalion has reached the city center, and elements of the 25th Tank Battalion, the 53rd Armored Infantry Battalion, and the 8th Tank Battalion are nearing the objective line.
Lommersweiler sees ongoing light fighting, with the elements of the 318th Infantry Regiment and the 35th Tank Battalion still trying to knock out the 2nd Company of the German 27th Fusiliers.
40 minutes later, a significant portion of CCB and CCR have made it into St. Vith proper. 7th Company of the 27th Fusiliers lurks in the forest east of Breitfeld, but it hasn't made many aggressive moves while I've been able to see it.
A twilight chill settles over the hills and forests of the Ardennes. Some of the CCR's units, including C/704 TD Bn, make their way to the southeast of St. Vith to help plug that flank. The fighting in the city center remains heavy, with US forces engaging at least two German headquarters units.
In Lommersweiler, the combined detachments from the 1/318 Battalion and the 35th Tank Battalion push 2/27 Fusiliers back to the west.
Nightfall comes at 6:00pm, twelve hours to scenario end (at which point I am judged by my superiors, no matter how close I might be to absolute victory). The American forces in St. Vith, led by A/704, begin to drive a wedge into the German contingent defending the northern edge of the town, while a smaller force pushes around to the northwest.
The concentration of German forces in the northern part of St. Vith looks denser and denser. I order the 35th, including its units detached to the south, to reorganize and move up to St. Vith.
This is as good a place as any to make the point that the appearance of passivity I've given thus far in this installment isn't that exactly: rather, I gave my orders early this morning, and modifying orders to CCR or CCB would take longer than I have to spare.
A few minutes later, C Company, 37th Tanks, to the northwest of 25th Cavalry Recon Squadron HQ, has finally recovered from its rout. In doing so, it has soundly beaten up on the infantry gun company that was right next to it.
Snow continues, of course. It's still below freezing temperature, although I wouldn't necessarily call that freezing in a figurative sense. Nor is it a major issue; its biggest effect is on fatigue recovery, and between now and the end of the scenario, the troops won't have time for that anyway.
The 37th Tank Battalion makes a flanking maneuver, while the heavy fighting in the center of the town continues. Having an overwhelming superiority in units is handy; it means that the German forces are more consistently under fire, which saps their fighting efficiency.
The 35th Tank Battalion, while making its way up the road, encounters a German company in the woods, which it promptly forces to retreat. This may be the 2/27 Company that had previously retreated from Lommersweiler, or it may be another. Either way, expect some supply disruptions overnight; it's very difficult to find units sneaking around in the dark and snow, so some supply columns might run right into them.
8:30pm arrives, and there isn't much to report. The 37th Tank Battalion pushes ever further north, the company the 35th Tanks bypassed is identified as the 5th Company, 27 Fusiliers, and a greater weight of forces arrives in St. Vith.
Once again, little to say an hour later. The 35th Tank Battalion reaches St. Vith, while the 5th Company, 27th Fusiliers pushes forward to menace the road. Two companies from the 10th Armored Infantry Battalion are tasked to push it back.
Just before 10:00pm, the balance of forces tips to the American side in St. Vith. The objective is, at least for the moment, ours.
In other news, supply columns returning to CCA's base from the front line suffer moderate losses, as I suspected might begin to happen.
The 37th Tank Battalion HQ, from its place in Neundorf, prepares to move up to St. Vith... except they forgot about the two companies of heavy tanks just to their north, and ended up having to fall back. Now that the enemy force is on the map, the 37th should path around them.
St. Vith remains in American hands. The 704th Tank Destroyer Battalion, although its units are split up among CCR's battalions, is proving to be a major factor in this battle.
St. Vith falls out of American hands in the next ten or fifteen minutes. The Germans must have units sneaking in to the north and east. Notice also that elements of the 10th Armored Infantry Battalion have forced the surrender of the 5th Company, 27 Fusiliers, which is one fewer supply disruption to worry about.
The 53rd Armored Infantry Battalion receives orders to attack north of the St. Vith objective. In doing so, they'll push the Germans further away from the objective and bring the force ratio more in my favor.
St. Vith has been recaptured, but it won't stick; a few minutes after I took this screenshot, it's lost again. The 37th Tank Battalion HQ knows enough to dodge the heavy tanks, now that they're marked on the map. It's now Day 5: six hours to go.
An hour later, the big story is transport column losses. Fortunately, this is happening in the last six hours of the scenario. That's a bit gamey; I doubt my superiors would look too kindly on my glossing over of losses to the supply lines just because I'm close to my current objective. Fortunately, they're not real, and they don't mind in this artificial scenario.
Another hour goes by, and the 35th Tank Battalion, which has been involved in nearly every major fight during this four-day battle, receives orders to once again go on the attack, pushing northwest from St. Vith's city center.
It's now 3:00am, another hour after the last picture, and the scenario ends in three hours. The 35th Tank Battalion is engaged with the forces to the north, and the 8th Tank Battalion now begins an attack to the east to widen the American perimeter. Even in this zoomed-in view, three gray crosses marking surrendered or defeated German units can be seen.
The town comprises three terrain types: town (the denser sort at the very center), village, and industrial (south of the two German units on the east road). Fortunately, they're all roughly the same for armored units: they're hard to navigate and present major obstacles to accurate fire.
The push to the north achieves some ground, while the 8th's push to the east meets lesser successes. Successes in the north prove to be sufficient, though, as I retake the objective at 4:59am, with one hour to go.
Another 30 minutes sees steady progress to the north and slight gains (but no losses) to the east. At this point I'm willing to call it.
And indeed, I am correct to do so.
There are a few things of interest to pull from the post-battle screen (and, for that matter, the revealed map in the background, but I'll get to that).
1. I missed a better-than-marginal victory by a few scant points, I think, and if I'd been a bit faster to St. Vith I could have had it.
2. Personnel losses favored me. I suspect this is because much of my early progress featured my tanks against German infantry. AFV casualties were more even, but given the German prowess in that respect and the fact that I was attacking, I'll take it.
3. A lot of German units ended up merging, and even once you discount those, seven of them were eliminated entirely. 233 personnel losses came from surrender, while only 4 came from bombardment and none from air strikes. In fact, German aviation and American friendly fire did better than American aviation, which is eyebrow-raising. Too, German bombardment proved more effective than American (although I submit that the American bombardments were more effective in blunting attacks and driving off defenses).
4. 11 members of D/37 Company managed to surrender before they were relieved.
Hitting that Review Final Situation button gives me a map with everything revealed. Handy.
On this one:
1. In the mess of counters at St. Vith is Peiper's HQ, which answers the question fo where that went.
2. The reason the heavy tank battalion southwest of St. Vith never moved is finally clear: the unit with the half-filled circle symbol is Peiper's Kampfgruppe base. Having a full brigade enemy brigade close to it must have spooked him; without it, his forces would have almost instantly been in bad supply shape. Such is the fog of war: if those three companies had attacked a few hundred meters east, they could have seriously thrown off my attack.
3. Speaking of supplies, the unit I thought was 7th Company, 27th Fusiliers was actually a division-level base, practically unprotected. That would have been nice to knock out, if I had known it was there. Such, as I just said, is the fog of war.
4. The stubbornly persistent 2nd Company, 27th Fusiliers was the cause of my supply disruptions. A/318 and the AT platoon didn't even notice it there through most of the night.
All told, I'm willing to take my marginal victory. Given my early blunders, even making it to St. Vith at all was fortunate. Hitting Peiper's HQ completely by accident and keeping the 501st Heavy Tank Battalion out of the fight by appearing to threaten Peiper's base probably won me the battle, and that's probably the greatest endorsement of this game I can give. This fictional scenario played out like so many real ones: a force moving at nighttime stumbles upon the enemy, engages them, and throws them into disorganization, and one commander, units perfectly placed to halt his enemy's steady advance, refuses to act because his intelligence is poor.
Thanks for reading. I probably had as much fun writing about this encounter as I did playing it. As a coda, I'm hoping for the patch to fix the halting bug to land before about December 20th. If it should, watch this forum around Christmastime for
The Battered Bastards of Bastogne: A Command Ops Christmas Special