Jim: Sure it's a little naive, but I just don't see him as scum. What's your read on him (Geen)?
He reads noob. (PPE: And then I caught up with his latest few posts.)
Saying that your read on him isn't scum is one thing, but outright saying he can't be scum because of his noobishness is another.
Jim:
#1
Your opinion on Geen ? And it's probably because you're an IC but i have a feeling i ignored the fact that you're also potential scum you too much.
See my response to Hapah concerning the same question.
Also, good, you shouldn't ignore that I could be scum.
Bah! Sorry if I suck at this, I'm used to just relying on seeing through bluffs. Also, I answered the questions a few pages back, and I just answered the other one!
No one cares if you suck, it only matters if you're trying.
I didn't vote for him because Hapah did! I'm just too lazy to quote anything . I'll re-read again and post in an hour or so with some quotes.
Why does his vote matter where you put yours?
Still no quotes for now.
You should use them, since they make understanding what you're getting at ten times easier.
Hapah: Why the hell are you attempting to protect me? Are you trying to make it look like we're buddying up? This is mafia, one of us is going to backstab and get the other lynched or nightkilled. I'm not going to be on the receiving end, which I'm suspecting you want me to be on.Unvote.
So if you're not going to be on the receiving end, then that must mean you're on the performing end.
This sounds a lot like you just admitted you were scum.
Oh! I see, this is different from what I'm used to. in the version I played, all scum would know who the other scum are.
RTFOP
Why do I keep getting the feeling that you haven't read the opening post or the rest of the thread in any amount of detail?
Did I say he extended because he is desperate to lynch someone? I did not. I did say he is very eager to lynch.
Wanting people dead is the norm.
Finally, my stance on no-lynch remains. You are entitled to your opinion, and I to mine. If we lynch a vanilla townie now, it's no big deal, after all it's still D2. If we lynch scum, that is great. What if borno was lynched and turned out to be, say, a doctor? We'd be in a much worse position. I refuse to lynch for the sake of lynching. If there is no consensus on someone being scum, then it's best not to lynch and see who the scum eliminate at night. One loss is always better than two.
I've already explained the merits of a lynch versus a no lynch so I don't know why you didn't pick up the lesson.
And power roles in role light games are usually so ineffective that worrying that a player
could be the doctor as a reason not to lynch someone is not a concern.
I believe that Hapah could be scum because of his desire to lynch. So for know I'm FOSing Hapah
Wanting people dead is the norm.
/broken record