Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Dustylou2]

Deathsword: kingfisher1112 flipped town. Who are you suspicious of now?

I think it's a bit too early to ask that, as I'm stil reviewing D1.

That said, I do have some suspicions, but until I get something solid I won't go around saying names.


Should have some questions later, I'm somewhat short on time right now.

Alright, just remember Toaster's Number One Scumtell.


Geen: Again, welcome to the thread. After reading through, does anything strike you as particularly suspicious? Why? Also, have you played any games of Mafia before?

[Hapah]

Kingfisher: I hope you'll play again!

Jim, Deathsword: How certain were you that KF was scum going into the lynch?

Geen: Welcome! Have you had a chance to read any of the past Beginner's Mafia games? The rules are pretty similar to the real-life deal, but it's an entirely different sort of game.

Dusty: Why do you think borno "jumped on the EasyLynchMobile", as you put it?

[Jim Groovester]

Why say he seems to be acting scummy? Why not just call him incredibly scummy? Why add all these pointless qualifiers?

I don't know, I guess just to add pressure.
Does one word really matter that much?

In the grand scheme of things, not really. But it could indicate that you're hesitant to directly call somebody scum, which is a mistake new scum players make everyone once in a while.

What are your suspicions going into Day 2 and why are you taking so long to post them?

I also wanted to know if you suspected all the players you cast votes for during Day 1 for the same reasons you claimed.

Alright, just remember Toaster's Number One Scumtell.

Where did you learn about Toaster's Number One Scumtell?

That said, I do have some suspicions, but until I get something solid I won't go around saying names.

What are you waiting for?

Jim, Deathsword: How certain were you that KF was scum going into the lynch?

Pretty certain.

My reasons for the vote are what I already listed: He had an emotional reaction and played in reaction to criticisms attached to people's votes. He looked a lot like panicky noob scum to me and I was very certain of my conclusion.

But I was wrong. Oh well. It happens.

Nice move, scum. And by that I mean 'WHY THE HELL DID YOU KILL AN IC ON N1?!'.

It's our lot in life to be N1 kill targets.

[Dustylou2]

Dusty: Why do you think borno "jumped on the EasyLynchMobile", as you put it?

I think he jumped on it because he doesn't care who gets lynched, as long as it isn't him or his scumbuddy. He's trying to slide through the day phase without doing any actual scumhunting.

Alright, just remember Toaster's Number One Scumtell.

Where did you learn about Toaster's Number One Scumtell?

I learned about it from a few of the games I read through from these forums. It was either one of the paranormals or a BM. Am I correct in thinking that it's promising content and failing to deliver? If I'm wrong, correct me so I don't screw it up again.

[Jim Groovester]

Yeah, that's Toaster's #1 Scumtell.

[Phantom of The Library]

The wind blew more swiftly above the city with nothing to block it or slow it down.  Were there any conversation it would have been drowned out, but no one had said much of anything yet, most were still trying to clear their minds of yesterday's frightening image and focus their thoughts on today's problem.

Attention all Players, the votes currently
stand as follows

[Hapah] {0}:
[Deathsword] {0}:
[Boltur] {0}:
[Geen] {0}: Dustylou2
[Dustylou2] {0}:
[borno] {0}:
[Jim Groovester] {0}:

Not voting {6}: Jim Groovester, borno, Geen, Boltur, Deathsword, Hapah
Replacement queue {0}:

Day 2 will end Thursday ~7:30 PM CDT
Current extension requests: zero. Three requests needed to extend the day.

The replacement queue is empty, please post in the thread or PM me if you'd like to sign up!

The LurkerTracker is a wondrous thing: Tracker for this thread

[Hapah]

Jim: Fair enough

Everyone Else: MOAR ACTIVITIES

Dusty: Do you have any insight as to why the person you replaced for did the same? (jumping on the easy lynch) He voted DS with no question attached.

[Dustylou2]

Dusty: Do you have any insight as to why the person you replaced for did the same? (jumping on the easy lynch) He voted DS with no question attached.

Unfortunately, I can't read minds. My earlier explanation of Fluffy's behavior still stands - that he didn't quite understand the differences between RL and forum-style mafia, and that your arguments need a logical basis to be successful.

[Jim Groovester]

borno, why are you lurking?

You're around the forums. Why not here?

But activity in general is pretty low. Everybody, post. Don't make me come after you. You will not like it if I have to play Mafia Truant Officer.

[Dariush]

Okay, okay, I'm posting, I'm posting. Happy?

[Jim Groovester]

Yes.

[Teneb]

Jim, Deathsword: How certain were you that KF was scum going into the lynch?

Very. He made quite a few slips and at the end he looked like desperate scum to me.

That said, I do have some suspicions, but until I get something solid I won't go around saying names.

What are you waiting for?

I like to back up my suspicions with either evidence or questions. You'll find both below.

Boltur: While examing D1, I've noticed a certain lack of scumhunting from you. When it comes to KF, all you did was ask him a weak question, and then accuse him when he failed to answer the question. You also called him out on his question after his rather angry answer, in which he asked two of the players attacking him (Hapah and myself) whom they though was scum.  Yet you asked something very similar not long before. You asked Mr Dwarfinton (your RVS vote) and myself (at the time with the greatest number of votes) what we thought of each other, and this question was asked after RVS ended. Were you trying to play us against each other? Maybe you were trying to look like you were scumhunting, when all you did was throw an RVS vote on Mr D and then jump on KF when he didn't answer a question. What do you have to say about your actions? After all, you claim that scum would go for an easy vote with a weak reason, and that is exactly what you did.

[blackmagechill]

Can I grab that replacement spot?
EDIT: Welp, missed geen's entry. I'll just wait for the next game I guess.

[Boltur]

Deathsword: kingfisher1112 flipped town. Who are you suspicious of now?

That said, I do have some suspicions, but until I get something solid I won't go around saying names.

Why you prefer not to reveal them if you have any ?

Borno: What do you learned from kingfisher death ?

Doustylou: Do you think we should try to gather information from night kill targets ? To what extent ?

Deathsword: What's "certain lack" ? I scumhunted or not ? Be more precise. Yes, my initial questions to kingfisher were not very content-heavy but his dodgy behavior was damning enough in my eyes to push harder. His answer was tailored to make us think he's town and while it was just mistake on his part as know now i interpreted it as scum defense. Not sure why you point it out. These questions i asked you and mr.D were to force the interaction between you two as i noticed you could be avoiding questioning each other which could indicate you are scumbuddies. Later i come to conclusion that looking for scum-teams before finding one scum is pretty useless so i gave up on that line of questioning. And there's nothing wrong with throwing a RVS vote and following by real one to me. You say my reasons for voting kingfisher were weak but what you made basis for a (i think) real vote is pretty weak itself. You completely disregard kingfisher's aggressive and nervous reaction which was the big thing back then. I admit that i got a bit too much focused only on the kingfisher yesterday and that's something i should avoid in future.

Hapah: Don't you think asking replacement for a reason of his predecessor actions is a bit futile ? Why not ?

[Dustylou2]

Deathsword: You said suspicions. Who else is suspicious?


Geen: Where are you? I still want my questions answered, and my vote is staying on you until they are.

Doustylou: Do you think we should try to gather information from night kill targets ? To what extent ?

Absolutely not. There's no way to know the motives of the scum or the way they choose their targets. Did they use Random.org? Kill Dariush to get him off their backs? Kill him because he was on someone else's back, in an attempt to incriminate them? We can't know. Questions like this are classic WIFOM. Why are you trying to confuse us, Boltur?