Godd job, now get Ishar back into the fight, that lazy guy laid in bed long enough. And name that Arclance guy for fixing it, if possible so that his dwarf does not die in the next round
Now, in regards to Darkhawk vs. Ishar
First: Artifact Mailshirt against artifact razorplate (breastplate, as far as i know)
As far as i know, mailshirts also protect the throat, but are less likely to intercept an attack, while breastplates (and razorplates) offer more protection, but on less space. But after all, you can throw that out of the window, because dwarfs can wear both, and quality isnt the biggest factor after all. And both is iridium, so many weapons will only glance away, if they come through at all. Ishars greaves still give him a small edge though, but then again, both dont get hit all that often.
Swords:
Darkhawk is attached to his runic weapon too, while ishar is attached to a normal one, which you cant change anymore because he will never drop it again (unless he dies, and at that point, it will not matter anymore). Point for my dwarfen badass.
Bindings:
Darkhawk is on the way to get stonebound, which should get him back on Ishars level in that regard. I never used the transformations, so i dont know which one is better in which situation, so both might have an edge in certain combat-environments.
Skill:
Darkhawk legendary, Ishar great, easy to understand who wins that one
Although i dont have every skill at hand, at least one of ishars should be legendary due to his "Turn megabeast into skill, PROFIT"-dwarfpimping.
Awesomeness:
Five sauropods just killed en route because they were there, a orc killed by biting through his mailshirt and a souleating sword that talks, questions?
But you know what? Screw this comparing stuff im doing here, because we will throw BOTH at our enemies, sounds like an idea