@U_P: If you overheard the conversation, then you'd know two things: Simus did not kill or attempt to kill Auron, she put him under, and even had the Doctor there to ensure she didn't kill him. No murder or even intent to murder occurred, so you can drop that complaint. It's not a valid one. The second is that she asked the doc to regrow your old body instead of you getting 'rewarded' with robot parts. The Doc hasn't agreed to that yet, so it's up to him on that one and why he hasn't done either yet.
Finally, you're asking me to punish for intent, not what actually happened. This isn't Minority Report. Yes, she wanted to do bad things to Auron, but she didn't - even if only because they were unfeasible. Meanwhile, Auron's being punished for insubordination (that is, disobeying direct orders from the person in charge by building the tank in the first place when standing orders were to get approval before starting any projects), assault with a deadly weapon (whether you were shooting to kill or are actually telling the truth about shooting to maim, the fact remains that you took a deliberate action to shoot someone else and were looking to take them out of action, temporarily or not), and property damage - all things he actually did. Simus only put Auron under unnecessarily and slightly delayed his recovery process. Comparing the cases, her single offense isn't as bad as any of your three. But you're right. I'll drop the Tinker ban. She actually needs access to Tinker to plan for the defense, and keeping her from it would hurt all of us in the long run.
Long story short, if you didn't want to deal with all the consequences, you never should have taken the shot. I honestly wonder how you would have tried to spin things if Simus hadn't been able to dodge the shot.)
Definition of murder: The unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another. (and yes Simus is still human despite her body)
Definition of killing: an act of causing death, especially deliberately.
Simus deliberately had the nurses remove her from her tank and carry her over to Aurons bed then disabled all of his life support and watched him die, her actions caused death and therefore consitute an act of murder. This fact is not altered just because she changed her mind afterwards and had the doc revive him.
"Long story short, if you didn't want to deal with all the consequences, you never should have taken the shot." Doesn't only apply to Auron, Simus could have gone straight for the coma but she instead chose to murder a helpless cripple and now she needs to face the music.
and no im not asking you to punish intent, im demanding you punish
attempt. if she had been stopped before the doc shot it down then yes it would have only been intent, but if you go to a hitman and they tell you that the method of killing you asked for is unfeasible it doesn't change the fact you just tried to hire a hitman.
Auron never acknowledged Simus authority over him extending past the survey and this was never corrected by Steve. even after the electrocution he only requested that Auron follow her orders, he never ordered it and he never stated that Auron was incorrect in assuming he was previously operating outside of Simus authority.
Auron can claim temporary insanity for the assault, Simus cant plead shit for murder.
and with the repairs Auron has offered to do the repairs personally with no assistance, this isn't exactly a new concept of atonement/punishment and is quite commonly employed.
you say Jim wants to avoid complications later on but punishing auron for ignoring the authority of those he was never instructed to respect, reflexively attacking someone who caused great pain to befall him and accidentally causing minor damages whilst allowing Simus to get away with premeditated murder, attempted personality removal and interference with his recovery without a single real punishment is gonna cause nothing but complications.