My action last night: tracking NativeForeigner with a staff of tracking, as he is one of the two reasonable possibilities for scumteam membership from my perspective, and the only active one.
NativeForeigner didn't go anywhere.Jack AT: Mr.D was a brother to you, wanted you to win, so claimed and flipped, but you didn't even raise an eyebrow about it. Are you a brother as well? There's been quite a few claims, but I don't think I've seen one from you. Please state in full your class, alignment and win condition.
Bookthras: ...what. There was no reason whatsoever for me to believe that Mr. D was my brother, beyond his vague "someone who is voting me is my brother" statement (note that he didn't claim to be my brother), until his flip. I didn't raise an eyebrow before the flip because I wasn't on at that time. I didn't raise an eyebrow about it after the flip because...
Urist I is correct. The wincon of the Brother is that the Brother wins if the player they are paired to wins. The Brother is not told the alignment/wincon of the target.
...it meant nothing, and all the relevant questions leading to it meaning nothing had been asked by the time I got to the thread. And this...how does it indicate that I'm a Brother? At all? If that's not what indicates that I'm a Brother, what exactly does?
In fact, how does any of that warrant even a FoS? This feels oddly flimsy, especially for this late in the game and from a veteran.
To answer your questions:
*While it would be amusing to have a Brother trying to make a Brother win, I am not a Brother.
*You have an interesting definition of "quite a few". I count a total two claims that aren't "I did this action" claims (That is, claims that aren't of the sort I've made): Imiknorris claiming ranger and Mr. D claiming brother. I may have missed something, but that's all I found. For the actual answer...I am town, I "when" (nice, Toaster) when all town-opposing killing and converting roles are dealt with. (I'd word it exactly like it was worded in the PM, but that would be against the rules.) I am a paladin via random class selection.
Finally, what are your thoughts on Hapah and Shakerag? You're speaking as if you think they could be third parties, but you don't actually seem to be examining that possibility. You're strongly pushing the conversation towards thoughts on Imiknorris and I, while your reasoning for your FoS on me is poor at best.
Boothras: First night, I used my scroll of hallucination on Falndre. Second night, I used the scroll of treasure detection (you can see why that's not worth claiming). This night, I used my scroll of ninja looting.
NativeForeigner: Why did you do each of these actions?
Okay. NativeForeigner has played consistently poorly throughout this game, giving little to no reasoning for any vote. He hasn't really questioned anyone until today. His votes, and I feel this must be mentioned again, have lacked reasoning. He also may have been blocked last night, and definitely didn't go anywhere, a possible reason for the lack of kill or successful protection.
On the other hand, Zathras's play feels off, in the ways I am questioning him about above. In addition, a block is a very good action for scum who decided to not kill: it explains the lack of kill and leaves the target of the block in a bad, rather lynchable position. This is not evidence against Zathras, but rather an explanation for why there wouldn't be a kill if he's scum.
For now,
NativeForeigner gets my vote. This vote is rather likely to move, though, depending on answers.
PPE:
Hapah, I generally take quite a while to write up my posts. Several hours per post, in fact. Usually, there is
much pacing involved.
Urist: Jack is looking suspicious, if only because he hasn't posted his actions or gotten involved in the discussion. He's around the forums: He posted while I was writing this up.
(Formatting added by me)
BULLSHIT. My last post on the entire forum was in this very game, during the previous day.