Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Hapah]

Hrm. Could be Planet, I guess. Or someone is full of crap.

And no activity tonight doesn't bode well. How long does the day have left?

[Tiruin]

You didn't answer my questions yet.

Which questions?

This is extremely unlikely as a town ability.

Like I said before, what exactly makes it such and what basis of comparison made you think so? Define "town ability" for me.

"Town ability" is very broad, but an unlimited use kill+RB does not fall under that category. Think about it. Its extremely unbalanced.
By the way, you haven't claimed using the kill ability yet. Why haven't you used it?

*Sigh*.

The reason I stated I didn't use it was because it's a one-shot, that would've subtly given it off for those who were actually reading into it. The reason why I didn't state that it was a one-shot was because I'm guarding the ability. The reason why I'm not using it was because I want to use my lore on kingsfoil. (Protect ; flavor for it. Kingsfoil is a medicinal herb.)

Besides, I'll ask you this. If you had a choice between a kill and a protect with no knowledge on everyone else's roles, what would you do?

I, would protect however.

Why are you so concerned if I choose to kill or not, ZU? You reflect damn everything. Oh, that may be very unbalanced. Very much unbalanced if I have to follow your thinking.

Strangely, you roleclaimed on incident, not because ToylK asked you to, if I have to remind you this.

Fullclaim:
My night ability is an automatic reflection of everything that is targeted at me. My other auto is that I know every action that is targeted at me. My 1-shot is that I can give another player a 1 use protect, roleblock, or inspect.
No one targeted me N1.

Let me round that question. Why didn't you use that one-shot? If so, why haven't you called it out? I mean, an inspect right there.

And look at all the autos! Very unbalanced indeed.

Could you state then, for us all, everyone who targeted you?

And yeah, it was confusing. I decided to check the Flash thing that Tiruin talked about once you brought up the contradiction, and it's a thing, much to my surprise (Overeager Vigilante). That's the only way I can read what he says that makes sense. Can't say that I've ever seen a game with one of those, though.

I can't figure what you mean here. "Makes sense?"

Extend!

So..I see others post, but no extend. Hm, assuming Captain Planet killed him then, he must be a vig as I've not seen anyone else claim the kill.

No one that died could have done it, and no one else has claimed the kill. I find it very unlikely that 2 scum would try to kill each other like this.

So we may have 2 mafia families, or Scelly is an SK or something? Is that what you're trying to say?

[zombie urist]

1. If I had absolutely no idea, protect. However, this does premise does not usually occur and even D1 gives useful info such that if I were a vig I may feel comfortable enough to kill.
2. My 1-shot is to give someone else one of a protect, block, or inspect. I haven't used it because I haven't found a suitable person to give it to.
3. N1 - Nobody; N2 - Tiruin, tried to take an ability.
I know for sure I answered some of these before.

No one that died could have done it, and no one else has claimed the kill. I find it very unlikely that 2 scum would try to kill each other like this.

So we may have 2 mafia families, or Scelly is an SK or something? Is that what you're trying to say?

No. I'm currently assuming Scelly to be town.

[Tiruin]

2. My 1-shot is to give someone else one of a protect, block, or inspect. I haven't used it because I haven't found a suitable person to give it to.

So of all of us, you haven't found even one person you could hope would use it well?

Tell me, what were your reads on everyone, before their flip.

[Hapah]

Tiruin: It's when you said this.

Or we have a vig that should kill every night.

The only way I could make sense of it is if you meant a Vig that HAS to kill every night. The "should" makes it kinda confusing.

[blackmagechill]

My internet was down for a few days, but from what I can gather, you guys are torn between me and Scelly because I used us to refer to the players left alive and it looked like a slip. And I did tell Powder Miner to Roleblock Tiruin during the day becuase I had a gut feeling, but he said it was a night ability that I should activate then and I had already set my suspicions on Zr2k.

I'm torn on my vote on Captain Planet, because on the one hand he has mostly been trying to bandwagon or get a kill or stay quiet, but he also hasn't been online in a week. Still voting for him until he either comes back or stays quiet.

[Powder Miner]

Vote, prod, timecounts maybe today but I'm slammed with homework,so I dunno.

[zombie urist]

Tell me, what were your reads on everyone, before their flip.

As much as I can remember:
OB - none
TolyK  - scummy
Borno - none
UI - none
Dariush - townish
Zrk2 - scummy
NativeForeigner - none
Phantom - scummy
Jack - townish
How does this help at all?

[blackmagechill]

Who's OB?

[zombie urist]

Orangebottle.

[Toaster]

Unvote. Toaster

Yeah, I don't buy your claim at all.  You're trying to make out like you're essentially helpless while someone makes you run off and kill people?  That smells like heap of bullshit to me.

This is the laziest shit I've seen. 

And your case on me isn't?

The biggest reason that I don't think Scelly is scum is the death of PotL. No one that died could have done it, and no one else has claimed the kill. I find it very unlikely that 2 scum would try to kill each other like this.

Or Scelly could be completely lying.  Also, if town is responsible for Phantom dying, why hasn't anyone fessed up to it?  You're ignoring the PGO possibilty.

No. I'm currently assuming Scelly to be town.

Why?



Scelly is scum because he's waffling over a claim that is clearly faked.  He's lying to cover something up, and that is most likely (as in 99% sure) because he isn't town.  Also, note his complete lack of scum hunting.  This is potentially LYLO and he's not even voting?  This is not town behavior.

[zombie urist]

Unvote. Toaster

Yeah, I don't buy your claim at all.  You're trying to make out like you're essentially helpless while someone makes you run off and kill people?  That smells like heap of bullshit to me.

This is the laziest shit I've seen. 

And your case on me isn't?

Meh.

Or Scelly could be completely lying.  Also, if town is responsible for Phantom dying, why hasn't anyone fessed up to it?  You're ignoring the PGO possibilty.

Its possible, but I'm going to believe it unless there is a counterclaim. I've thought about the existence of a PGO, but it doesn't match up. None of the dead players had a PGO-like ability and none of the living players claimed it.

No. I'm currently assuming Scelly to be town.

Why?
Scelly is scum because he's waffling over a claim that is clearly faked.  He's lying to cover something up, and that is most likely (as in 99% sure) because he isn't town.  Also, note his complete lack of scum hunting.  This is potentially LYLO and he's not even voting?  This is not town behavior.

Because he is the only one to have claimed killing Phantom, who was scum. I highly doubt two scum would do something like this.

[Toaster]

So how did he kill Phantom if I saw him visit Borno?

[zombie urist]

Maybe he did both?

[Toaster]

So your theory is he had an untraceable kill in addition to his traced kill?  That seems highly unlikely.