Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Argembarger]

nothing to see here

[Darvi]

Nominate Kingmaker 4. Duh.

[Argembarger]

Yes, that's a given.

Speaking of Kingmaker 4, I really want all the newbies involved in that game to keep playing Mafia, and get really good, and then go back and read through that game in about 6 months, and then post their thoughts here.

[Vector]

Please view my comments in the other thread.

[Jim Groovester]

Is a hall of shame something the mafia board really needs?

Even if it were used impartially as an archive of demonstrably bad play, it still doesn't seem like that great of an idea to show everybody examples to avoid instead of examples to emulate.

[Vector]

I will add that there is already plenty of bad play to observe in the "excellent" games we have in place.  NSBM1, for example, had some really terrible things going on.  BM1 was a serious clusterfuck.  These games were added, however, to show scumteams getting out of tight spots with dignity and flair.

[Jack A T]

I can't see this thread working out well.  Too likely to lead to anger.

[Vector]

I'm going to apologize for saying "be my guest" and making this mess happen in the first place.  I should have had better judgment than that, and I'm sorry if I come off like a hypocrite.  I'm really tired... need sleep to make the brainmeats work again.

[Argembarger]

Eh, it's my bad, I read "be my guest" as "this is an acceptable idea".

Locking.