Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

Author Topic: Dwarven Dumbness  (Read 1300 times)

Dotto

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Dwarven Dumbness
« on: August 07, 2008, 03:20:11 pm »

Iīm playing DF for almost two weeks and, even though still a newby in the game, as I see, the main aspect of the game, the one that captiveted me, was not having direct control of the dwarves and their low level of intelligence. Itīs kind of cute, like a tender feeling, seeing them traped in their little world, almost a fatherly look. That creates, I think, a distant intervention, or an indirect one, and makes me try to keep them happy and healthy.
BUT, although very difficult for me, maybe for my little time in the game, i would try to draw a line to separate what contributes to this game experience and what would be improoved in the inteface to make it easier to play. Being able to control each single workshop - not having to select in the z menu what goods will be usable or not -, or not needing to follow a three or four step sequence to change their weapons or whatever, these are some elements that doesnīt please me. Does someone agree with me?
Logged

Neoskel

  • Bay Watcher
  • Read or the owl will eat you.
    • View Profile
Re: Dwarven Dumbness
« Reply #1 on: August 07, 2008, 03:24:29 pm »

Indubitably.  ;)
Logged
Urist Mcsurvivalist has been accosted by edible vermin lately.

Goblins: The fourth iron ore.

Teeto_K

  • Bay Watcher
  • Deforesting Woodland Biomes
    • View Profile
Re: Dwarven Dumbness
« Reply #2 on: August 07, 2008, 06:11:41 pm »

It is the little things that irritate, but my love for the game continues unabated. It's been quite a while since a game has captured not only my interest, but also my imagination to the extent that this game has. I think the last was Half-Life-2, but sadly, the game just doesn't have the same magic going back to it that it did when I first started, and it was a short game, as shooters tend to be.

Meanwhile, I'm probably cresting the 50 hour mark in DF, and still going strong. But I know what you are saying about the interface, I have a small story to relate that is related or at least will be related, once I relate it.

My current fort is my first "keeper", a fort that I have confidence in, that I have not ruined with thoughtless channelling and liquid use, poor planning, or glaring weaknesses. I like it. When I first embarked, I noticed that the map had a Giant Eagle. I was worried, but after a couple seasons of watching him stick to his perch in the mountain tops, not bothering anyone, I figured I'd be okay.

Fast forward to my first immigrant wave: I get a hunter. He quickly busies himself with cluttering my butchery, because he is much more competent at hunting than my peasant-trainee butcher/tanner is at Butcher/Tanning. I reallocate some jobs, and enjoy happily the steady supply of skull totems, bone bolts, leather bags, and meat and fat for cooking that he provides. The diet in my fortress expands in variety, and I feel proud that I'm able to provide better than my previous vegan-only menu.

Several seasons later, I get a message on my announcement page that takes my breath away:
Code: [Select]
'Ceilinggang' Hunter/Clothier cancels Hunt: Unconscious.
I already know what has happened before I make it to hit "u", scroll down, and use "c" to zoom to him. When my view centers on the scene, it's a horror show on the heights overlooking the valley my fort is in. Blood is everywhere, and spent crossbow ammo litters the ground. I see dwarf chunks, and can hardly bear to open the wounds menu. On initial inspection, my precious hunter lays prone at the feet of the Giant eagle, unconscious from the pain of a severely mangled right hand. The foul beast who looms over him menaces with all the menace that a capital "E" can muster, and with a heavy heart, I realize that my newbie millitary probably won't make it in time, they're still slow in their chainmail armor. I issue the orders anyway, and unpause the game.

A miracle happens: The eagle bleeds to death from it's wounds mere moments later. I didn't know old 'gangy had hurt him so bad. My spirits are only lifted further when even more impressively, Cielinggang wakes up momentarily and begins dragging himself down the mountainside toward the fortress, lapsing in and out of consciousness as he goes. I'm hopeful, as it appears that he is no longer bleeding.

I disable the entrance traps as a temporary measure, remembering the new "feature" in this version that would likely finish him off. He makes it, unaided, to the fort, then to his room, and plops down in his bed to rest.

And rest he does. For months. And months. The hand isn't getting better, it's still mangled, though fortunately it appears my fortress denizens are dutiful in bringing him water and food. He compliments the cooking, but bemoans the lack of alcohol, but is at least happy to be well tended to in his quarters, which though modest are quite well appointed for a common working dwarf in a fortress of 1 year. He remains in good spirits as he continues his convalescence.

1 year later, the fort is a bustling villiage of 52 dwarfs. 2 hunters came in last year's immigrant wave, and are working to fill the void left by Cielinggang's need of rest. I check up on him occasionally, to see how long it is before I have a third hunter. The local wildlife is populating fast enough to keep my hunters busy, and I need bags for my bustling farm industry that is making me a killing at the caravans. (The merchants always leave pleased, we're dwarves who know the value of our goods, and know the value of good relations with those who have what you want.)

One fine autumn day, I notice that the hand has healed some! It's still broken, but it's progress, and I'm quite pleased.

However, I suddenly notice something that I had not noticed in all this time: There is more content on the wounds menu that I can scroll down to see. A pang of fear shoots through me, and as I overcome my hesitation and reach for the "plus" key, my worst fears are confirmed.

Ceilinggang's wounds are much worse than I'd thought. He suffered moderate brain damage, and had lost both of his eyes. He's not going to recover. My heart sinks, after having maintained hope all this time, watching the young upstarts try to fill his shoes, patiently waiting for the day he'd be able to get up and show them how a REAL dwarf hunts. No pansy groundhogs foxes and deer for him; he'll tackle the real game! Giant Eagles, by the score! Yeti, Aligators, whole packs of wolves will flee before his unerring eye and deadly steel bolts.

I pause for a moment, realizing that I didn't have the heart to put him out of his misery. So, I put my best mason and best carpenter, and my legendary engraver to work. I expanded his quarters, and outfitted him with decorated high quality furniture, smoothed over and engraved the walls. Put up a statue depicting him aiming his crossbow at unseen game over the horizon. And I hunted through the stockpiles, and found the "Giant Eagle Skull Totem" that had been made from his kill.

Now we get to the part where the interface frustrates me: I can't seem to get the dwarfs to place the totem in his room. I set up a 1 tile stockpile that only accepts skull totems, forbade all the other totems, and made the stockpile take from the stockpile the Giant Eagle skull Totem was in.

Nothing.

I wish it was easier to move specific objects around. Tables and Chairs and Beds are cake, but I want to hang his last trophy, that he earned at such high price, in his room, for all to see and remember, and it seems I can't.
Logged
Refar Wrote:
Quote
They have not mastered the art of safe fishing, safe drinking of booze, safe [you name it]... Why would someone think they mastered safe sex?

How I dorf:
http://mkv25.net/dfma/map-3901-thecitadelofartifice

Quiller

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: Dwarven Dumbness
« Reply #3 on: August 07, 2008, 06:41:54 pm »

Kill any dumps you may have.  Set up a dump area in his room on the stockpile.  Find the Eagle Totem and set it to be dumped.  Wait until someone gets around to doing it.  Remove the dump zone and go back to whatever your normal dumping procedure is.  That's the best that I can think of.
Logged

Reasonableman

  • Bay Watcher
  • ...Probably.
    • View Profile
    • Twitter is dead, long live Cohost
Re: Dwarven Dumbness
« Reply #4 on: August 07, 2008, 06:47:30 pm »

Your description of DWAAARF FORTRESS made me think of Lemmings, for obvious reasons, which I have rather fond childhood memories of. Now I love DWAAARF FORTRESS even more.
Logged
A sane man must be reasonable, but a reasonable man need not be sane.

Willfrey

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: Dwarven Dumbness
« Reply #5 on: August 08, 2008, 12:17:31 am »

I think there is more human dumbness than dwarf dumbness.  I had been getting seiged regularly on one of my first forts, and still didn't really  understand how to work up a military, so i just closed off my fort.  I had opened it between seiges to do little things here and there, (try to fish, farm, hunt..)  One of my hunters was killed by a siege, and I shut my gates.. or so I had thought.. 

Cue all my idling dorfs running out to loot their fallen Hunter's goods.  I lost about twelve dwarfs that day.
Logged

bretrags

  • Escaped Lunatic
    • View Profile
Re: Dwarven Dumbness
« Reply #6 on: August 08, 2008, 09:05:55 am »

Original topic: I agree wholehartedly.

About Teeto_K's problem: turning "on" the Eagle skull totem in the stockpile in his room is not enough. Be sure you also disable (turn "off) all eagle skull totems in the original / all other stockpiles.  Eventually, the dwarves will get around to moving the totem to the right stockpile, bless their OCD hearts...

At least, this is what I have done in the past to get my artifact oak blowguns to their own stockpile...  :)
Logged

Quiller

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: Dwarven Dumbness
« Reply #7 on: August 08, 2008, 06:21:01 pm »

It can also help to undesignate the stockpile where it currently resides, as dwarves seem to prioritize moving loose items to stockpiles over removing items from stockpiles where they no longer fit.  At least in my experience.
Logged