Only one person willing to give feedback?
I guess I need to show you a working copy of the game so you can try it out yourselves and then maybe I can get a few people stating their opinion.
I am running a public weekly snapshot system, where every Monday (plus/minus a few days) I upload a new version. These versions often have bugs in them, but they are cumulitive and each version is smarter than the last one and includes all the previous bugfixes. I already uploaded snapshot 1 and 2. Unfortuantelly, I chose MegaUpload to do this and now MegaUpload has been taken down.
I won't reupload snapshots 1 and 2, but snapshot 3 is going to go up on IndieDB. I am just waiting for approval. Anyway, IndieDB should be a more reputable host than MegaUpload (not that I am against/for it and what has happened to MegaUpload). So once things are approved I invite you all to download and try.
Anyway, I created a new GUI for creation mode specifically. It is designed to be intuitive and very easy to use both with mouse and for people preferring a lot of keyboard shortcuts. Let me post a screenshot:
So my question to you is this: without getting any explanations regarding this GUI, what do you understand from it? Do you think you could use it at first sight?
To Terraria players: I bet this is more familiar to you. Ignore the lack of icons and textured GUI.
To DF players: do you recognize anything from that picture? How do you feel about a fully realized 3D experience vs. ASCII/graphic packs? What I personally love about 3D is that one can play from a semi-traditional top down view and then with a press of a button instantly switch (without loading times) to a first person view and walk around:
PS: I noticed that all pictures on this forum are embedded in spoiler tags so I've done so too. Is this some kind of an official/unofficial rule?