This looks like it could be a lot better than Spore... if they finish it someday. I've been wishing that someone would make a game like Spore, but better. I hope they'll pull it off.
I don't totally hate Spore, but I don't have a highly favorable opinion of it either. I think I need to give it another try sometime, but the rhythm mini-games were a bit annoying and out of place. If I wanted to play a rhythm game, then I'd go play one dedicated to that. The game also seems to crash a lot. Many people may disagree, but I still very much prefer No Man's Sky to Spore. IMO, it's my game of the year, but I don't see it actually winning that award anywhere. The funny thing is that I was never "hyped" for Spore, but I was for NMS. I don't totally agree with all the outrage toward NMS, but I can honestly understand why people are disappointed too. I like the game for what it is, and I hope they'll make some content updates, but they did promise things that aren't there, for whatever reason.
I guess I just started playing NMS with the expectation that some things would be cut. I doubt the devs are malicious supervillains, but it would be a good idea for them to change the official screenshots and videos on Steam. Sadly, it's a common thing for features to be cut/excluded from games, but it seems to happen more for some games than others. Using tricks to make a product look 10x better is a very annoying type of thing that's common in advertising (anything) overall.