Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Tea]

That's p abstract as i doubt you'd have been having the same argument in that case. Prob wasn't pro-roo's wincon to get into it with you on D3 at least. The only question I thought was important that you were asking about was the one I followed up on so idk? I thought you and Dorsid were focusing on the wrong stuff when trying to read roo (the motivation for roo not answering stuff seemed obstinate town rather than scummy, as opposed to Dark Star.)

[Tea]

I'm not sure what you meant by a acceptable though so I'm not sure I answered that sufficiently.

[Deus Asmoth]

Blankly refusing to answer questions is rarely a good thing for town or scum. Several of my questions to roo were asking him to justify a bunch of seemingly random accusations he'd made about me, and I'd have been perfectly able to use his refusal to back them up to leave my vote on him on day 2 if I hadn't gotten caught up in trying to be clever.

[4maskwolf]

Asmoth, where you slipped up was aggressively poking the cop claim when there were no counterclaims and no jailkeeper claims.  There was no reason to disbelieve the cop claim, so it was fairly easy to see who the scum was at that point, particularly since you voted first and he voted you afterwards.

It would have been very difficult to slip out of that situation regardless, so it's not really your fault, but yeah...

[Tea]

Will there be another beginner game soon? I'm afraid people will like want to lynch me for my playstyle if I branch out

[Shakerag]

There might be a bit of an activity lull right now until all these poor bastards still in school get done with finals. 

As far as playstyle is concerned ... I can't really speak for everyone, but my main rule for mafia, regardless of playstyle, is to have solid reasoning behind what you do.  Lynch vote on a player?  This is why I'm voting him/her.  Protected that person?  This is why.  Whether town, scum, or other just don't get caught with your pants down when someone questions you as to why you did something.