Auratus' Share:
Red Dragon Armor: +10, Dragon Bone Ship's Wheel: +7, Ruby Trumpet: +7, Golden Staff: +7
Total 31
Tulwor's Share:
-Strange Shark-Tooth Whip: +7
-30 Pounds of Adamantine Wafers: +20
-Jorgen Flaut, Captive Pirate Captain and Warrior: +8
-Cephlidquid, Captive Pirate Officer and Shark-kin Sorceress: +12
Total 47
Pyrite's Share:
-15 Dread Pine cones: +50
-Nell Hound, Captive Pirate Officer and Water Elementalist: +8
Total 58
Up for discussion between the Gods
-
Up for even distribution, or payment to the Dread Pirates
-50000 Redsport Dubloons: +15
-350 Gallons of Kracken Ink: +20
-250000 Assorted and Poorly Organized Coins and Gems: +30
Up for imprisonment
-Mild Red, Captive Pirate Officer, First Cousin and Wife to Wild Red: +1
-Tilda Thorn, Captive Pirate Captain, Adopted Daughter and Mistress to Wild Red: +4
-Holland Wik, Captive Pirate Captain and High Priest of the Robber Dragon: +5
Fate yet undecided
-Makko Hogshead, Captive Pirate Captain: +4
-Ogov Flave, Captive Pirate Officer and fleet tactician: +3
Up for public cooking & subsequent devourment
-Corpse of Wild Red: +1
Pyrite might have some generic nondescript use for Makko Hogshead or Tilda Thorn, but the elementalist seems like a better fit for him than Auratus. I get the feeling Auratus will end up wanting the priest as well. I'm also mildly curious about the kraken ink just because it's organic, but I have no idea what it does other than be ink. Should probably ask.
Other than that, we've got a shopping bag, one or two Redport tokens of indeterminate value, and a lot of currency and vague loot that nobody seems much interested in.
Auratus' Share:
Red Dragon Armor: +10, Dragon Bone Ship's Wheel: +7, Ruby Trumpet: +7, Golden Staff: +7
-Holland Wik, Captive Pirate Captain and High Priest of the Robber Dragon: +5
-250000 Assorted and Poorly Organized Coins and Gems: +30
-1/3 of the 50000 Redsport Dubloons: +5
Total 71
Tulwor's Share:
-Strange Shark-Tooth Whip: +7
-30 Pounds of Adamantine Wafers: +20
-Jorgen Flaut, Captive Pirate Captain and Warrior: +8
-Cephlidquid, Captive Pirate Officer and Shark-kin Sorceress: +12
-350 Gallons of Kracken Ink: +20
-1/3 of the 50000 Redsport Dubloons: +5
Total 72
Pyrite's Share:
-15 Dread Pine cones: +50
-Nell Hound, Captive Pirate Officer and Water Elementalist: +8
-Makko Hogshead, Captive Pirate Captain: +4
-Ogov Flave, Captive Pirate Officer and fleet tactician: +3
-1/3 of the 50000 Redsport Dubloons: +5
Total 70
Up for discussion between the Gods
-
Up for even distribution, or payment to the Dread Pirates
-
Up for imprisonment
-Mild Red, Captive Pirate Officer, First Cousin and Wife to Wild Red: +1
-Tilda Thorn, Captive Pirate Captain, Adopted Daughter and Mistress to Wild Red: +4
Fate yet undecided
-
Up for public cooking & subsequent devourment
-Corpse of Wild Red: +1
So
probably it'll end up looking something like this, barring any communal payments to the Dread Pirates or Canvas, assuming loot numbers and loot values maintain their ratio when divided, ignoring whether Redsport Dubloons or Kraken Ink is more valuable to anyone in particular, Hogshead is somewhat useful and Thorn isn't, and so on.