1
DF Dwarf Mode Discussion / Re: Why not crossbows?
« on: October 21, 2008, 04:07:34 pm »Actually, medieval (european or otherwise) crossbows were extremely inaccurate, and couldn't go very far. Their main advantage was that they hit so damn hard that it didn't matter, and you didn't need much training to use one.Where are you getting this information from? Sure, crossbows in general are less accurate at longer distances than bows since you lose sight of your target when you have to point the crossbow up at an angle to get arc, but they are easier to be accurate with than bows against targets that can be aimed at clearly. I seriously doubt that medieval crossbows were extremely inaccurate considering that most reproductions I've seen have been very accurate, and back then life or death could depend on hitting your target.
They were most effective at mid to close range, where infantry with no armor could cut down scores of heavily armored opponents without breaking a sweat.
If you think about the typical dwarven crossbow user as firing from behind fortification from above the enemy as they approach the fortress, the crossbow is pretty much the best possible weapon in that situation.